You’ve probably seen the news reports over the last few months regarding a heart condition in dogs called Dilated Cardio Myopathy (DCM). In case you haven’t, this post will sum of what’s being said, along with what’s missing from the conversation.
A report came out earlier this year as the result of a study currently looking at DCM in dogs. One thing this particular group had in common is that they were eating a grain-free dry kibble. Because of that, a theory is now being looked into that states grain-free diets – which may use peas, lentils, and potatoes in place of wheat, corn, rice, and others grains – could somehow contribute to DCM. Shortly after the report, the FDA even issued an official warning about the potential link between grain-free diets and DCM in dogs.
It’s important to note that DCM and other heart conditions have been studied for years in an attempt to discover the cause. Years ago it was thought to be purely genetic, popping up in a small number of breeds such as dobermans, golden retrievers, and a few others. Since then, however, it has been discovered in other breeds breeds as well.
The grain-free link is one of many theories. Here are a few others:
- Lamb and rice kibble (not grain free)
- Low protein / high carb diets (can be grain-free or grain inclusive)
- Dried beet pulp
- Genetic predisposition
- Leaky gut syndrome as a result of processed diets in general and toxic environment
- Lectins and antinutrients in legumes (and most grains) are blocking the body’s ability to create and absorb taurine
- Too much fiber in the diet could be blocking absorption of taurine
A few important points regarding the studies currently being done:
- The issue is seen in dogs eating grain free and grain inclusive diets
- About half the dogs tested in one study were deficient in taurine, the other half weren’t
- There is more documented evidence of DCM in dogs eating grain than there is grain-free
- Grain-free accounts for about half of all pet food sold in the U.S. Therefore from a numbers perspective, it makes sense that some dogs with DCM are eating grain-free.
- Most of the specific grain-free foods being named are low protein. The same has been true of the grain inclusive foods named in the past.
Taurine is an amino acid that is found exclusively in animal products such as hard working muscle meat, heart, eggs, seafood, and raw dairy. Taurine is essential for heart health and a host of other functions. However, it is not considered “essential” by AAFCO for dogs to actually consume. This is because dogs can synthesize their own taurine as long as they consume enough of the amino acids methionine and cysteine. What has been found in dogs with DCM is that about half are deficient in taurine and half aren’t. But in both cases, taurine supplementation seems to help as part of treatment.
A huge problem that I’m seeing in the news reports and in conversations with concerned customers is that taurine is hardly, if at all, being mentioned. I’m having conversations with folks who’ve just come from their conventional veterinarian that has told them they have to start feeding their dogs grain because grain-free diets are causing heart disease. Most of these pet parents haven’t even heard of taurine. That’s a problem, considering taurine deficiency is what these researchers believe could possibly be one of the causes of the DCM they’re studying.
Now this is important to consider: grains do not contain taurine. So how will the simple act of consuming grain help with taurine deficiency if grains can’t supply it? Now, the reverse is also true. Legumes and potatoes don’t contain taurine either. DCM and taurine deficiency is being seen in dogs that are eating both low animal protein grain-free and low animal protein grain-inclusive foods. The issue, in my opinion, is that dogs aren’t consuming enough meat because that is where taurine and the other essential amino acids are found.
Not All Grain-Free Diets Are Equal
Consider a balance raw diet vs a grain-free kibble. They are both grain-free, but so very different. In a balanced raw diet there are very few carbohydrates. Most that we carry range from 2% to 5% carbs. There usually isn’t any grain, legumes, or potatoes found in such a diet. Instead, the diet is made up primarily of meat with a small amount non-starchy produce. As we know, meat is where all of the amino acids are found in a way dogs can most efficiently use them.
Compare that to a grain-free kibble. In the grain-free kibble there might be anywhere from 20% (on the low end) to 60% (on the high end) carbohydrates. From a purely general carb percentage perspective, that isn’t any different from a high quality kibble that includes grain. Even lumping all grain-free kibbles together is a poor point of view, as you can see above.
In the 80s, cats were dying left and right from DCM by the thousands. By then most of these cats were eating primarily dry kibble that was low in meat content and high in grain. It was discovered that taurine deficiency was the cause, so it became mandatory for cat food to have minimum levels of taurine either in the food itself or by adding a taurine supplement to the food. What followed? The issue was taken care of.
Now, look at all the cats today that are eating grain-free food. They aren’t having this issue with DCM from taurine deficiency because the food is still supplemented with taurine.
I personally believe that it is in fact essential for dogs to consume taurine just as it is for cats. That’s partly because their most natural diet of primarily raw meat and organs would supply a lot of taurine. Why aren’t grain-free high animal protein kibbles, cans, and balanced commercial raw diets being included in these incidences? In my opinion, it’s because the dogs on these diets are consuming higher amounts of taurine, along with higher amounts of the other amino acids that help them to produce taurine.
Where Do We Go From Here?
First of all, if you’re concerned about taurine deficiency in your dog, have your vet test for it.
It’s important to understand that there is no solid proof in any of the theories so far. Unfortunately, that’s not how the news and opinion pieces written by some folks in the pet industry are laying it out. They seem to be calling theory a fact and that can be dangerous when no one really knows yet.
We also must be sure to not take twenty steps backward, as some in the industry are pushing individuals and veterinarians to do. Going back to feeding corn, wheat, and by-product based foods not only won’t solve the problem, it will bring on a whole host of other issues once again.
In light of all this, I recommend doing what I have always recommended doing. Feed your dog as species-appropriate as you can afford. Holistic veterinarians are recommending the same thing.
- If you feed dry kibble, feed ones that are high in animal protein and low in carbohydrates. You want to look at the amount of carbohydrates, not simply whether or not they’re grain-free or grain-inclusive. Be sure to rotate inside and outside the brand so as to offer a wider variety of nutrients, being sure to stay in the same quality range.
- Include as much raw or freeze-dried dog food as possible. Whether it’s 100% or 10% of the diet, it can make a difference. High meat canned food would be next best to help cut down on the carbs.
- Occasionally include foods like fresh eggs (local and pasture-raised if possible), fermented raw goat’s milk, sardines, mussels, and freeze-dried heart treats in the diet. These are excellent sources of taurine and a load of other nutrients.
Other dry foods, such as Nature’s Logic, Carna4, and Orijen have high naturally occurring levels of taurine, methionine, and cysteine as a result of their high meat content. Nature’s Logic uses a low-glycemic grain as their starch source. It’s interesting to note that millet compared most other grains and legumes doesn’t contain near the amount of lectins.
Carna4, in both their grain-inclusive and grain-free foods, contains very high levels of amino acids thanks to their minimal processing. The phytic acid and antinutrients that are often found in seeds, grains, and legumes are cut down significantly thanks to the sprouting process that Carna4 uses.
High Quality Grain-Inclusive Dry Kibble
If because of all the hype right now you just simply feel more comfortable feeding a food that includes some grain that’s totally fine. We have some great ones. Again, my stance has always been that low carb and high meat is ideal, not whether a food simply includes grain or not. I’d recommend stopping in to check out Carna4, Nature’s Logic, and Wysong to name a few good dry foods that include grain.
Taurine is important, but it isn’t more important than any other nutrient your dog needs. That’s why I always recommend the variety I listed above. There isn’t one perfect food your dog can consume day in and day out that will allow her or him to thrive. They need a variety of nutrient-rich and species appropriate foods.
Grain-Free Dog (and Cat) Food, Taurine, and Heart Disease by Jean Hofve DVM (one of the best articles I’ve read on the subject)